Extrajudicial writings describing actual court cases disguised as fiction – Part Three

In his fictional autobiography, Judge Timothy Philpot discusses many real life events both outside and within his courtroom including descriptions of actual cases. Listed below  are the third set of disguised characters and clues about their actual identities
Disguised characters: Janet Guy and Darius Barnhart
Background: Janet and Darius are Paternity Court litigants. Janet is described as “A typical young lady who got pregnant and became eligible for government benefits and knew the father was in jail. A drug addict, with six kids by five women. She never planned to be anything other than a single mother, just like her own mother.” Paternity confirmation is needed in order to obtain government benefits and DNA testing  shows  that Darius Barnhart  is Janet’s  “latest baby daddy”.  Darius claims he is unable to pay child support which caused the judge to muse on the absence of black responsibility: “On some days the sadness was overwhelming. When most or all of the men in orange jail jumpsuits were African-American, the judge would ask himself, Where are all the black pastors? What happened in the African-American culture that led to this day, when nobody seems to be married, children are born to single moms and the fathers are not working, not educated, and often not caring? Where’s Jesse Jackson? Where’s Al Sharpton? Is this my fault? Am I a racist for even having these thoughts?”
Disguised characters: DeJuan  Wilder and his girlfriend
Background: DeJuan Wilder is a litigant in Dependency, Abuse and Neglect Court.  He petitions the judge “Hoping to get custody of his daughter. He’d just gotten out of prison, but since the mother was on drugs and the child was in foster care, he appeared to be a decent alternative—until more facts came out. Judge Z decided to drug test him, and when he was asked who he lived with, he pointed out his girlfriend in the courtroom. She would need to be drug tested.” DeJuan’s white girlfriend is understandably upset at being targeted for drug testing  accuses the judge of being racist. The judge cannot understand how another white person could have standing to call him racist:
“Judge Z thought that was odd, since she was as white as he was, but he brought her back into court and asked her if she would rather apologize or go to jail. She reluctantly mumbled “I’m sorry” and the overcrowded jail was spared one more big mouth to feed.”
Disguised characters: Laura Mahoney, Louisa Franke, Rachel Fielding and unnamed legal aid clinic supervisor (Court officers and social workers conspiring to promote abortions in family court)
Background: In the book, the judge is strongly pro-life. He has attended demonstrations and been disciplined for showing gory ant abortion videos to pregnant teenagers. He even slips pro-life helpdesk numbers to women considering abortion, in his courtroom. It is inevitable therefore that he eventually clashes with female judge Robin Newton who is “staunchly and openly pro-abortion.” She is the preferred choice of social workers seeking “judicial bypass’ for minor girls who want an abortion without getting their guardian’s permission.  Judge Philpot’s alter ego stumbles upon the racket when the female judge goes on vacation without covering her tracks, and he is called to preside over the case of Ivory Smith, a poor, black, drug-using teenager. Laura Mahoney is Ivory’s Legal Aid attorney who attempts to arrange an abortion for Ivory but is foiled by the judge after he manages to persuade Ivory’s grandmother to withhold permission. Not content with getting his way, the furious judge launches something of a witch-hunt to identify abortion friendly people in his court. He upbraids Louisa Franke, Ivory’s social worker and Rachel Fielding, a prosecutor for status court who denies complicity, as an innocent bystander. The judge circles back to Laura Mahoney who is forced to seek help from her supervisor at the legal aid clinic, a bow-tie wearing man in his fifties who  coaches Laura in reminding the judge that:
“I know that conversations with my client are privileged. And I know abortion is legal. And I know that this court is not supposed to consider evidence of what happened in conversations in a courthouse hallway.”
These reminders of due process and court rules seem to come as something of a shock to the judge:
“Judge Z was surprised. Her boss, a more seasoned lawyer, had given her good answers. The judge was now on the defensive. He took his time.”
Disguised characters: Barry Murdock, his daughter Serena Murdock and her boyfriend Sam
Background: Serena, a twenty-six year old mother of a six-year-old boy, is a litigant in the judge’s Drug Court. The judge recognizes her as the daughter of an old friend, Barry Murdock who “had quit drinking and drugging, had been to AA meetings every night for a year and Jesus was now his Higher Power”.
Unfortunately, Serena’s familial drug habit had forced the judge take her son, Ray, away from her two years prior. “The father was missing, of course. She was on probation for various drug offenses, but drug court had saved her life. “
Serena and her boyfriend are one of only two couples who receive redemption in the autobiography. The dozens of non-redeemable characters are virtually all minority, non-Christians who are relegated to damnation and continued suffering.
To earn her favored status, Serena forgoes an abortion after being handed a pro-life helpline phone number by the judge in court. She then pays homage by attending the funeral for the judge’s mother and marrying Sam. Serena and Sam show their gratitude by changing their daughter’s name to that of the judge’s mother and live happily ever after.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s